Martha’s Vineyard is a treasure trove of local flavor, and coffee lovers will be delighted by the variety of unique, independent coffee shops scattered across the island. Each café offers a distinct atmosphere and an array of delightful brews, from classic espresso to innovative specialty drinks. Let’s dive into the best coffee shops that Martha’s Vineyard has to offer, each one providing a memorable experience for island visitors and locals alike.
Toccopuro Coffee
Toccopuro Coffee at 45 Circuit Ave., Oak Bluffs (508-338-2463), is a must-visit spot on Martha’s Vineyard. The shop’s quirky, lab-like décor and a wide array of coffee gadgets create a unique atmosphere. Friendly barista Chad recommends standout sandwiches like the Emerald Pearl with grilled chicken, mozzarella, and vibrant pesto. Cool off with a refreshing bubble tea and enjoy a picnic in nearby Ocean Park. You can also visit their original location at 3 South Water St., Edgartown (774-549-9351).
Behind the Bookstore
Behind the Bookstore is a charming café nestled behind Edgartown Books at 46 Main St., Edgartown, MA (774-549-9123). Known for the best coffee on Martha’s Vineyard, it’s an ideal spot to relax with friends or family, offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner under the stars. Open from May through fall, the café features outdoor seating, great cocktails, and delicious vegetarian dishes.
Catboat Coffee Co.
Catboat Coffee Co. located in Tisbury Market Place at 79 Beach Rd B11-B12, Vineyard Haven, MA (774-563-5296), is a year-round destination for coffee lovers. This cozy shop offers specialty beverages, Lebanese sandwiches, dips, a rotating selection of artisanal cheeses, and island-made goods. Open seven days a week from 7 A.M. to 4 P.M., it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious coffee and a taste of the island’s unique flavors.
Cozy Corner Café
Cozy Corner Café, located at 238 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown, MA (508-939-3988), is a European-themed, modern café known for its high-end single-origin coffee and espresso, expertly crafted by Martha’s Vineyard Coffee & Co. It’s an ideal spot for those seeking a quiet place to work, a cozy setting to meet with friends, or simply a peaceful retreat to unwind. In addition to premium coffee, the café offers a variety of breakfast sandwiches, paninis, full-service smoothies, and açai bowls, with gluten-free and vegan options available.
Espresso Love
Espresso Love is a lively and welcoming café nestled behind the Edgartown courthouse at 17 Church Street, Edgartown, MA (508-627-9211). Known for its wide selection of homemade pastries, sandwiches, and gourmet coffee, everything is crafted with the freshest, highest-quality ingredients. Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee and pastry on the go or enjoying a leisurely afternoon with a good book, Espresso Love offers the perfect setting to relax and indulge. Open daily from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM.
Mocha Mott’s
Mocha Mott’s, founded by Mott Hinkley in 1994, is a beloved coffee spot with its flagship location at 10 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA, and a second location at 15 Main St., Vineyard Haven, MA. Owned by Tim Dobel and Meredith Aldrich since 2001, both locations offer organic, fair-trade coffee and espresso, homemade baked goods, and Cape Cod bagels. In the off-season, you can also enjoy homemade soups and specials. Known for its lively atmosphere, Mocha Mott’s is where locals and visitors come together for good coffee and good times. Call 508-696-1922 for Oak Bluffs or 508-693-3159 for Vineyard Haven.
Chilmark Coffee Company
Chilmark Coffee Company, located on Martha's Vineyard, is a small-batch coffee roaster renowned for its commitment to exceptional quality. Not a retail storefront, the company focuses on roasting specialty-grade coffee and provides comprehensive training to help customers appreciate the care that goes into each batch. They source their coffee from producers who are fairly compensated, supporting reinvestment in their farms and communities. For more information, they can be reached at 508-560-1061. The company is open Monday through Thursday from 9 AM to 2 PM.
Edgartown Meat and Fish Market
Did you know you can get your Starbucks fix at the Edgartown Meat and Fish Market? This spot is the only place on the island offering Starbucks Coffee, making it a convenient stop for provisions, beach sandwiches, and your favorite coffee beverages.
Back Door Donuts Bakery
If you’re in the mood for a donut and coffee combo, Back Door Donuts Bakery is the place to be. Located in Oak Bluffs, this beloved bakery serves delicious pastries and coffee, perfect for enjoying by the harbor. Location: 5 Post Office Square, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557 Phone: (508) 693-3688
Black Dog Dockside Café
At Black Dog Dockside Café, you’ll find a convenient spot by the harbor offering breakfast sandwiches, wraps, and fresh pastries alongside their stellar espresso and coffee options. Location: 12 Circuit Ave Ext, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557. Phone: (508) 693-2291
Nat’s Nook
This cozy café on Main Street in Vineyard Haven specializes in crepes, espresso drinks, and teas. Nat’s Nook is perfect for a sweet treat paired with locally roasted coffee from their own brand, East to West. Location: 38 Main St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568. Phone: (774) 563-8518
Waterside Market
Waterside Market in Vineyard Haven is known for its consistent quality and community feel. Alongside their coffee offerings, they serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, making it a beloved spot for locals and tourists alike. Location: 82 Main St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568. Phone: (508) 693-8899
Little House Café
Little House Café in Vineyard Haven is a humble yet delightful spot offering a variety of espresso drinks and baked treats. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a coffee to go, this café’s welcoming atmosphere will make you feel right at home. Location: 339 State Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568. Phone: (508) 687-9794
Delicious MV Bakery
Specializing in authentic French breads and pastries, Delicious MV Bakery also serves organic, fair trade coffee and espresso drinks. It’s the only coffee shop on the island where you can also get ice cream! Location: 32 Beach Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568 Phone: (508) 338-2562
From hidden garden spots to bustling community hubs, Martha’s Vineyard offers a diverse array of coffee experiences. Whether you’re exploring Toccopuro’s bold flavors, enjoying the literary charm of Behind the Bookstore, or savoring the community spirit at Mocha Mott’s, the island’s coffee shops cater to every taste. So take a moment to sip and savor as you explore the best that Martha’s Vineyard has to offer.
