Shop Local, Shop Unique: Consignment Stores of Martha's Vineyard

Daryl Perez


Martha's Vineyard, the beautiful island off the coast of Massachusetts, is renowned for its breathtaking beaches, lush landscapes, and high-end boutiques. Yet beneath the veneer of luxury, there exists a world of thrift shopping waiting to be explored. In this blog post, we'll embark on a journey to discover the finest second-hand stores and consignment shops on Martha's Vineyard, including Lower Deck Consignments, Act Two Second Hand Store, Second Treasures MV, Chicken Alley Thrift Shop, and Island Vintage. Prepare for a treasure hunt like no other!

Lower Deck Consignments: A Hidden Gem in Edgartown

Lower Deck Consignments in Edgartown is a must-visit for fashion enthusiasts. Stop by and explore a wide array of clothing and accessories, with new inventory arriving weekly. Enjoy guilt-free shopping with the best prices in town, and discover the perfect additions to your wardrobe in this charming consignment store.

Act Two Second Hand Store: Thrift with a Twist

Act Two Second Hand Store on Martha's Vineyard is a non-profit thrift shop with a mission. It exists to support the local arts and education community, providing grants to non-profit organizations that promote theater, music, and visual arts on the island.

When you shop at Act Two, you're not only finding great deals on a variety of items but also contributing to their cause. The store recycles clothing, jewelry, art, furniture, and housewares while offering affordable shopping for locals and visitors.

Second Treasures MV: Where Every Item Tells a Story

Second Treasures MV is a Martha's Vineyard vintage shop known for its diverse Gallery Collection, featuring antique collectibles, furniture, paintings, sculptures, porcelain and glass items, as well as silver, gold, and jewelry. This unique store offers a range of unique pieces, including a miniature MV Ag Fair Poster, Orthodox Icons, Robert Immelt's Martha’s Vineyard Artist Window, Ludwigsburg “Venus and Cupid” figurine, Victoria Carlsbad Austria Oyster Plates, and a Silver Tea Set, catering to collectors and those looking for distinctive additions to their collections.

Chicken Alley Thrift Shop: Thrift Shopping with Heart

Chicken Alley Thrift Shop in Vineyard Haven is not just a thrift store; it's a beloved community hub. As one of the largest sources of financial support for the organization, it holds a special place in the hearts of Islanders and visitors alike. This social hotspot relies on volunteers to keep the business running, with donations from the community providing a diverse inventory. From artwork to home goods and clothing, you'll find everything from A to Z under one roof. Explore this thrift shop for great deals and discover hidden treasures, all while supporting the vital programs of MV Community Services.

Island Vintage: Capturing Coastal Charm

Island Vintage Edgartown is a popular clothing store located in Edgartown. The store offers a wide range of stylish and trendy clothing options for both men and women.

They are known for their selection of casual beachwear, including t-shirts, shorts, swimsuits, and accessories. Island Vintage Edgartown also carries a variety of high-quality brands, ensuring that you'll find pieces that are both fashionable and durable. Whether you're looking for a new outfit for a day at the beach or a night out on the town, Island Vintage Edgartown is a great place to shop.

Exploring Martha's Vineyard's Thrift Shopping Culture

While Martha's Vineyard is known for its upscale boutiques, its second-hand stores and consignment shops offer a delightful contrast, revealing the island's rich thrift shopping culture. These shops not only provide an opportunity to discover unique items with character but also allow you to contribute to sustainability efforts and support local charities.

So, when you find yourself on this enchanting island, take some time to explore Lower Deck Consignments, Act Two Second Hand Store, Second Treasures MV, support the community at Chicken Alley, and capture the coastal spirit at Island Vintage. Martha's Vineyard's second-hand stores are waiting to be discovered, and you never know what hidden treasures you might stumble upon during your visit to this charming destination. Happy thrifting!


As a team, we work in harmony for the benefit of our clients. We handle multiple transactions at once and are able to execute a complex marketing strategy by leveraging team resources. We can be in several physical locations at once to ensure showings are always possible for our buyers and sellers. Our clients benefit from the combined experience of our agents and administrative staff.

Let's Connect
Follow Us