49 Old Courthouse Road, West Tisbury, MA 02575
49 Old Courthouse Road

49 Old Courthouse Road

49 Old Courthouse Road, West Tisbury, MA


  • 5 Beds
  • 5 Full Baths
  • 1.6 Acres Lot
  • 3,580 Sq.Ft. Living
  • 1971 Year Built
  • Sold Status
  • 37399 MLS® ID
CHARMING & BUCOLIC IN WEST TISBURY - 2 majestic Oak trees guard the entrance to this pastoral setting of meadows, gardens and woods. Home to the Bayberry Inn for 30 years, this property is looking for a new owner with fresh vision for its next chapter. One may continue the Inn tradition, enjoy it as a single family residence or operate an assisted living facility here. Permits for a care facility are already in place and all requirements have been met. Old Courthouse Road is a quiet country lane with miles of trails that are ideal for walking and biking. With over 3,500 square feet this home has five bedrooms and ample living spaces. The unique Octagon sunroom addition has been a favorite place for family and friends to gather. This room is spacious and features a 15 foot high ceiling and a copper top roof that reverberates with musical sound during rain storms, making an ethereal sensation of peace and wonder. There is a formal living room with built in book shelves, a fireplace and a bay window that overlooks the large yard. Two working fireplaces add to the charm of this well loved home. Outside you will find a brick patio off of the dining room, a private backyard and a small orchard on the side yard with 7 different varieties of fruit trees. There is an attached garage that has been transformed to finished space, ideal for an additional bedroom. Miles of walking trails can be accessed at the end of Old Courthouse Road, as well as trails to Priester's Pond, just down the road. State Road Restaurant, Middletown Nursery and North Tisbury Farm & Market are just around the corner. Lambert's Cove Beach is also nearby and is an additional benefit to ownership in West Tisbury. Additional bedrooms are allowed and a new 7 bedroom septic system has been installed.
Show MoreShow Less
Jen Hawkins O'Hanlon, REALTOR®

Jen Hawkins O'Hanlon, REALTOR®

Team Leader



  • Total Bedrooms5
  • Total Bathrooms5
  • Full Bathrooms5
  • Flooring2
  • Fireplace2
  • APPLIANCESStove: Y, Washer: Y
  • other interior FeaturesFloor 1: Enter through the front door into a large hallway The kitchen is open to the dining room that features a fireplace and sliders out to the terrace that overlooks the expansive yard There is one first floor bedroom and a large living room with fireplace and bay window There is a bonus room on the first floor that could be used as a den or office Through this room you ll find the wonderful family room in the newer addition (2005) This unique octagon room has windows all around and creates a cozy, light filled atmosphere Lastly, on the opposite end of the first floor, there is a laundry room plus a converted garage that would be ideal for an additional bedroom/manager s apartment, should the property be utilized as a care facility or Inn, Floor 2: Upstairs there are three spacious bedrooms, all with ensuite baths

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area3,580 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area1.6 Acres
  • MLS® ID37399
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1971
  • View DescriptionNone, Pasture


  • Water SourceWell
  • utilitiesCbl
  • lot featuresLarge
  • parkingAmple
  • HEAT TYPEElectric
  • sewerSeptic Tank
  • SubstructureConcrete
  • other exterior FeaturesGarden, Patio, Pub Bch


  • Sales Price$1,300,000
  • Real Estate Tax $6,048
  • Zoning RU


As a team, we work in harmony for the benefit of our clients. We handle multiple transactions at once and are able to execute a complex marketing strategy by leveraging team resources. We can be in several physical locations at once to ensure showings are always possible for our buyers and sellers. Our clients benefit from the combined experience of our agents and administrative staff.

Let's Connect
Follow Us