Specializing in Real Estate Sales and Luxury Vacation Rentals
Melanie was born and raised on Martha’s Vineyard, all of which she spent growing up in Katama and riding her bike into Edgartown. After graduating from Quinnipiac University with her BS in Business Management & Entrepreneurship, she returned to the Island full time to work in the family business, luxury custom home builder Colonial Reproductions. She remains the head of Client Relations working directly with her clients and their decorators to aid in all aspects of the building selection process, while also working in real estate. Her construction knowledge is an invaluable resource for her clients and a huge benefit to the O'hanlon Group team.
On All Reviews
Of Real Estate Experience
Obtained Brokers License
Interior photos coming soon!! Here is your opportunity to build your family compound in the heart of Katama! Located 1.5 miles from Downtown as well as South Beach and right near the bike path, this property offers easy access to all things Edgartown! Short Walk or Bike ride to Field Club as well...
$1,795,000
Price2
Beds2
Baths912
Sq.Ft.
Nestled in the heart of Edgartown, this historic residence offers a perfect blend of timeless charm and modern comforts. Enjoy a leisurely stroll to shops and dining, a front-row view of the 4th of July parade, and easy access to Fuller Street Beach.This two-story home features a well-appointed k...
$2,550,000
Price4
Beds2
Baths1,704
Sq.Ft.
Welcome to this meticulously maintained 2+ bedroom, 3 bathroom end unit condo in the prestigious Tashmoo Woods Association, built in 1998.The updated kitchen, with granite countertops and high-end appliances, opens to a dining room with access to a private deck overlooking lush woods. The living ...
$1,450,000
Price2
Beds3
Baths1,682
Sq.Ft.
A desirable location in Vineyard Haven and just steps away from Owen Little Beach on Vineyard Sound. This home offers privacy and endless possibilities while being close to Downtown Vineyard Haven shops, restaurants, harbor and ferry. The home features an inviting porch overlooking a spacious law...
$1,232,500
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,308
Sq.Ft.
Immersed in the picturesque setting of Oak Bluffs on Martha's Vineyard, Fairview on Greenleaf Avenue, one of only ten homes in this coveted location, harmoniously blends historical charm with coastal serenity. This cherished family home holds a special place in the hearts of its owners, with root...
$2,990,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,608
Sq.Ft.
Experience the ultimate luxury lifestyle at this exquisite Martha's Vineyard estate. Situated in a private location with commanding views of the Atlantic Ocean and Chilmark Pond, the property offers safety and serenity, perched on an elevated site well above the flood zone. Chilmark House, design...
$17,590,000
Price6
Beds7
Baths7,160
Sq.Ft.
Welcome to this enchanting Edgartown home that seamlessly blends timeless charm with modern updates, nestled on a quiet street. This house exudes a sense of old Vineyard charm making it a truly captivating haven for those seeking a unique home. As you approach the property, its welcoming front po...
$3,000,000
Price4
Beds4
Baths2,006
Sq.Ft.
House, guest house and studio! Located just outside of town and close to beaches and harbor, this unique property includes a 4 bed/2.5 baths. Many nice features include an open living, dining and kitchen, fireplace set up for a wood stove, wood floors and a first floor primary with en-suite bath ...
$1,500,000
Price5
Beds4
Baths2,329
Sq.Ft.
SERENE RETREAT IN KATAMA - Discover your perfect vacation home in Island Grove, mere moments from the soft sands of South Beach and the charming streets of Edgartown. This residence is not just a home; it's a launchpad to the quintessential island lifestyle, with unrivaled access to local gems li...
$1,985,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths2,162
Sq.Ft.
Discover the charm of this welcoming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch, located just a short drive from the lively center of Oak Bluffs. Set on the corner of a quarter-acre lot, the property offers ample opportunity for expansion, allowing you to tailor it into your ideal summer getaway or a cozy year-...
$720,000
Price2
Beds1
Bath816
Sq.Ft.
Situated in a quiet neighborhood, this .25-acre lot offers a level and square space, perfect for building your island home. The location is ideal - just about two miles from the lively downtown of Oak Bluffs and less than a mile from the Lagoon Pond town landing for fantastic boating or kayaking....
$465,000
Price
Nestled in a coveted private enclave on Martha's Vineyard, this charming 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath Cape-style home offers an idyllic retreat on 1.65 acres. Experience exclusivity with deeded access to a serene private beach on Lake Tashmoo, a mere five-minute stroll away. Designed with an open layout, ...
$1,800,000
Price4
Beds3
Baths2,044
Sq.Ft.
A delightful neighborhood in the heart of Oak Bluffs. This land offering is located within close proximity to the various public access points to the sandy shoreline of Lagoon Pond. With engineering in place, embrace the unique opportunity to build your own custom residence. Whether you envision ...
$409,000
Price
WATER VIEWS from almost every room in this home. Mooring permit transferred with home sale (current waitlist 6 years) The full service "Safe Harbor Vineyard Haven Marina" is 1/4 Mile down the road (See website link). The potential is endless with this ranch boasting 5/4 bedrooms and 4 full bathro...
$2,600,000
Price5
Beds4
Baths2,276
Sq.Ft.
Nestled down a scenic country lane and just a leisurely bike ride away from the vibrant town center, this delightful Vineyard Haven cottage offers the perfect blend of convenience and tranquility. The idyllic retreat is not just a home; it's an access pass to the serene pleasures of Lagoon Pond w...
$849,900
Price2
Beds1
Bath962
Sq.Ft.
Your Martha's Vineyard retreat! Anchored by the charm of a classical, New England-styled, Greek Revival residence. Relax in a tastefully crafted island home for all seasons, easy to maintain and use. Comfortable living on three floors, with mahogany-bunged yellow pine flooring throughout. Exposed...
$1,625,000
Price3
Beds1
Bath1,560
Sq.Ft.
Custom built two story Colonial located in central West Tisbury. This expansive home built by an island craftsman includes Black Locust trim, mix of Wide Pine, White Oak, Pink Elm and Brazilian Cherry solid hardwood floors and a floor to ceiling stone fireplace. Kitchen with center island, as wel...
$1,795,000
Price5
Beds3
Baths3,026
Sq.Ft.
This charming 3 room cottage has tons of potential and is sited in a sweet spot off South Rd. Chilmark near the public boat landing and town center. Oriented towards the sunsets with ample privacy, you can almost see the pond from the 2nd floor deck. Lived in for the past 20 years, this home is s...
$1,050,000
Price1
Beds1
Bath816
Sq.Ft.
Magnificent Impeccably-maintained Edgartown Estate. Rare 5-acre compound in the heart of Katama, surrounded by 17 acres of Sheriff’s Meadow conservation property and across from the Nature Conservancy’s Farm Institute. Sited and designed by architect Jack Kemper to provide both sanctuary and larg...
$6,950,000
Price5
Beds8.5
Baths7,500
Sq.Ft.
Enjoy single-level living in this charming ranch-style home located one mile from Oak Bluffs Harbor and Downtown and just down the road from Lagoon Pond. Relax on the private back patio, covered front porch or the wrap-around deck. Open concept living room and kitchen features granite countertops...
$997,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,064
Sq.Ft.
This charming Katama home with many recent improvements by the seller is perfectly located on a lovely side street off the left Fork to South Beach. You can be at South Beach in 5 minutes by car, or enjoy a bicycle ride to the beach on the nearby bike path. The house is nicely set back from the s...
$3,250,000
Price4
Beds4
Baths2,407
Sq.Ft.
* Seller would consider credit toward buyer closing costs to be used toward an interest rate buy down, paid points to reduce interest rate and Landbank Fee. Welcome to your enchanting farmhouse sanctuary in Island Grove! This serene retreat seamlessly harmonizes country charm with contemporary c...
$2,250,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths2,162
Sq.Ft.
Step Into History: Edgartown Village Home with Distinctive Heritage - This historic residence situated in the heart of the town offers a multitude of attractions. You can leisurely walk to the array of shops and dining establishments, enjoy the view of the 4th of July parade from the front porch,...
$2,550,000
Price4
Beds2
Baths1,704
Sq.Ft.
A DIAMOND IN ISLAND GROVE - Nestled amidst the enchanting beauty of Martha's Vineyard, discover a slice of paradise in the coveted Island Grove neighborhood located between Edgartown Village and Katama. Welcome to a truly exceptional retreat, where timeless elegance meets modern luxury. The resid...
$2,250,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths1,875
Sq.Ft.
Welcome to your West Chop Haven! Nestled in an established neighborhood, this 1980 home boasts a bright and inviting ambiance that will make you feel right at home. With three bedrooms, it is a perfect retreat for you and your loved ones. Step inside and be greeted by a delightful blend of contem...
$1,050,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,140
Sq.Ft.
Discover an exceptional opportunity in the desirable Mill Hill neighborhood. Tucked away behind a meticulously crafted custom gated driveway, this remarkable property presents 3 distinct living spaces, each with its own private entrance. Immerse yourself in the charm & versatility of this captiva...
$3,400,000
Price4
Beds5
Baths2,498
Sq.Ft.
Classic New England Cape lovingly maintained sits on 1/3 of an acre in a central Vineyard Haven neighborhood, convenient to downtown, Tisbury School, ferry & Tashmoo.This one owner home features hardwood floors throughout, first floor primary bedroom, cook’s kitchen with stainless appliances whic...
$1,200,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths1,768
Sq.Ft.
Coming Soon: Showings start July 9th. 3BR 2BA turn-key home is close to the ferry, shopping & restaurants that Tisbury has to offer. This Vintage 1930’s bungalow is truly an Island oasis. This home was updated in 2011 with new updates this spring. Enjoy coveted one floor living. The cozy kitchen...
$1,200,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,230
Sq.Ft.
Here's the perfect opportunity to make your Vineyard Dream come true. Check out this spectacular location tucked away in Edgartown. Steps away from Morning Glory Farm and a short ride into town and beaches. This home currently has two bedrooms with the potential of seven, with proper approvals an...
$1,399,000
Price2
Beds2
Baths1,450
Sq.Ft.
Introducing a charming home in Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, offering convenience and tranquility. Nestled in a sought-after location, just a stroll from the town center, this property features post and beam construction, vaulted ceilings, and an open concept design. The first floor includes a m...
$1,250,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths2,135
Sq.Ft.
RARE OPPORTUNITY to build your family compound on this acre and a half parcel in the private Witchwood association with association dock. With proper permitting, up to 8 bedrooms allowed. This is the first lot on Witchwood Lane, bordering Katama Road and the bike path leading to South Beach and D...
$3,060,000
Price
OAK BLUFFS BEACHFRONT AND DOCK- Spectacular frontage and views of Vineyard Haven Harbor are achieved from this classic three-bedroom, two-bath home. The charming cottage has been well maintained and offers a practical layout that will easily accommodate all who visit. However, not much time will ...
$1,700,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,196
Sq.Ft.
Renovated in 2019, this sweet & petite cottage is located 2 blocks from Upper Main Street and just a short walk to all the activity of Edgartown Village. Recently connected to the town sewer, this lot will now permit up to 4 bedrooms with plenty of room to expand on the lot. A built-in pool would...
$1,330,000
Price2
Beds1
Bath589
Sq.Ft.
This commercial condo space is located in the heart of Oak Bluffs, conveniently situated near the harbor and bustling with plenty of foot traffic. The commercial condo is versatile, allowing for a wide range of uses, from retail to office space to service-oriented businesses. However, it cannot b...
$500,000
Price1
Bath
Sunny contemporary beach house with many recent improvements: roof, bath, siding. Still some updating to do so bring your ideas and imagination. Level 1/2 acre lot allows for 4 bedrooms so think expansion or maybe even a guest cottage. Large main level deck and a 2nd floor deck/balcony off on...
$1,153,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,697
Sq.Ft.
Nestled in a private and serene location, this magnificent property offers stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and Chilmark Pond. As you enter the home, you will be greeted by tall ceilings, oak flooring, and natural light. The fire-placed living room with floor-to-ceiling windows and the spacio...
$17,590,000
Price6
Beds6
Baths7,160
Sq.Ft.
Nestled on Simpson's Lane, discover this classic Edgartown Colonial at the heart of the village. Walk to Fuller Street Beach, dine in excellent restaurants, and explore charming boutiques steps away. The open-concept first floor flows seamlessly from entry to kitchen, dining, and living areas. A ...
$5,490,000
Price5
Beds4
Baths3,535
Sq.Ft.
Love being in downtown Edgartown? Want to generate income when you can't be here? Welcome to Edgartown Commons - a seasonal, condo/hotel on Martha's Vineyard that offers a combination of private condo ownership and investment opportunity. Unit 16 is a unique second-floor unit located in the main ...
$415,000
Price1
Beds1
Bath529
Sq.Ft.
This gracious three-bedroom, 3 1/2 bath Colonial is sited at the top of a winding driveway in the midst of expansive lawns, gardens and treed acreage. It is tastefully screened with numerous flowering shrubs, plants and specimen trees. The floor plan is intelligently designed and offers one floor...
$2,000,000
Price3
Beds4
Baths2,620
Sq.Ft.
CLASSIC EXPANDED CAPE WITH SALTWATER POOL & DOCK SLIP - Quietly tucked away in the desirable Witchwood area of Katama surrounded by mature woods for total privacy. Combines great outdoor space around the pool area, with newly refreshed indoor spaces. First floor features a large Family Room with...
$4,200,000
Price5
Beds3.5
Baths4,475
Sq.Ft.
ROOM FOR A POOL! MOVE-IN-READY CUSTOM CAPE WITH FARMER'S PORCH AND ATTACHED GARAGE. Grandfathered FIVE BEDROOM per Edgartown Wastewater Dept. Three blocks from Edgartown Village. This well-maintained and thoughtfully renovated home is waiting for its next family. With an additional 1100sqft of ...
$2,000,000
Price4
Beds4.5
Baths2,676
Sq.Ft.
This spectacular Edgartown harbor front compound was newly built in 2009 and offers 3 buildings with over 7,000 sq. ft. of classically designed living space offering great flexibility in use. The main residence offers a cathedral ceiling living room with fireplace and antique beams. The home has ...
$15,400,000
Price6
Beds7.5
Baths6,346
Sq.Ft.
Location is always key and this home allows easy access to South Beach, Farm stand, downtown Edgartown or up island. Large landscaped property allows room for garage and or expansion. Ability to connect to Town Sewer for up to 7 bedrooms. Open kitchen living area floor plan that leads to a 3 seas...
$795,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,128
Sq.Ft.
Look no further for the upcoming 2022 summer season than this four-bedroom, three-bath home in the heart of Katama! The open and functional layout makes entertaining a breeze, accented by a fully equipped chefs' kitchen and multiple living spaces. A detached garage, in addition to the ample stora...
$3,050,000
Price4
Beds3
Baths2,955
Sq.Ft.
This charming home is located near the bike path and less than 2 miles from town, yet tucked away down a country lane. With this prime location comes deeded access to the Lagoon Pond, which is perfect for kayaking, boating and swimming. There is also a walking path nearby that connects to 16 acre...
$1,050,000
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,260
Sq.Ft.
EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITY - Expanded ranch with full basement and large garage on a level 1/2 acre lot in Vineyard Haven. The property is being sold AS IS. OPEN HOUSE on Saturday, February 19, from 12-2pm. No showings prior to the open house.
$905,000
Price3
Beds1.5
Baths1,534
Sq.Ft.
IMPECCABLY UPDATED & MAINTAINED BUNGALOW - Truly in move in condition, this home has been restored and renovated by both the current and previous owners. The location on State Road lends itself perfectly for an easy jaunt to Cronig's or Vineyard Haven's Main Street. This is a unique opportunity t...
$855,000
Price3
Beds1.5
Baths958
Sq.Ft.
HOME FOR THE HOLIDAYS - Move right into this meticulously maintained and recently updated Edgartown property. Bold Meadow is a well established neighborhood of approximately 50 homes. Owners enjoy a bucolic setting with tennis courts and access to miles of state forest trails, as well as the pave...
$1,475,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths1,700
Sq.Ft.
A PRIME KATAMA LOCATION - This property is positioned to take advantage of everything Katama has to offer. Surrounded by 180 acres of conservation land, you will enjoy views of the Atlantic ocean and the plains of Katama. The heart of the home includes an open concept on the second floor with sli...
$2,650,000
Price3
Beds3
Baths1,932
Sq.Ft.
CHARMING EDGARTOWN VILLAGE COTTAGE. This charming one-bedroom, one-bath cottage is a perfect pied-a-tier, located within walking distance to all the best of Edgartown Village. This home is sited on a conforming R-5 lot, is already connected to Town Water and Town Sewer and will support a future...
$1,150,000
Price1
Beds1
Bath560
Sq.Ft.As a team, we work in harmony for the benefit of our clients. We handle multiple transactions at once and are able to execute a complex marketing strategy by leveraging team resources. We can be in several physical locations at once to ensure showings are always possible for our buyers and sellers. Our clients benefit from the combined experience of our agents and administrative staff.
Let's Connect
